A few days ago, Seth Godin asked why ethical marketers wouldn’t be “eager to have aggressive, clear and well-defined regulations” (about marketing).
He set the context by talking about the lies used to sell sunscreen, noting that lobbyists kindly helped the FDA water down proposed sunscreen regulations.
To quote Seth:
Why aren’t ethical marketers (of any product) eager to have clear and well-defined regulations, creating a set of honest definitions so that they can actually do what they set out to do–make a difference and make a living at the same time? If you’re busy competing against people willing to cut corners, I’d think you’d want the rules to be really aggressive, clear and obvious.
Yes, clear and obvious regulations would be great, but the assertion that we need more regulations to deal with them requires that I call BullSeth.
Enforcement and Influence
The enforcement of existing regulations in a fair and consistent manner is the primary issue.
Selective enforcement of these regulations is sometimes used to send a political message to some industries while others are left to their own honor or lack thereof.
At times, the agencies responsible for enforcement find themselves taking direction from elected officials who often take direction in the form of campaign contributions. At other times, these agencies do whatever they like, regardless of regulatory boundaries created to manage their work.
Before the everything-is-one-party’s-fault types weigh in, keep in mind that this ISN’T a (R) problem or a (D) problem. It’s universal regardless of the animal you represent.
A healthy business / consumer / economic environment doesn’t require oppressive business marketing/advertising regulations like Germany’s, we need those who represent us to use the existing regulations in a fair and consistent manner AND continue to improve them.
Smart businesses can’t sit around and wait for that to happen.
Don’t Wait, Educate.
Waiting for these changes isn’t going to cut it. Smart businesses educate prospects and customers about the quality choices they have.
That doesn’t mean your marketing has to be boring (far from it). It doesn’t mean your marketing can’t be compelling, entertaining, motivational and most importantly, effective – but it can be all those things without breaking existing laws, much less new ones.
In the meantime, we have to do our part to eliminate the slimeballs. Yes, I absolutely mean put them out of business, even if it means a game of Whack-a-Mole as they close one and start another.
Ethical business people don’t do enough to call out the slimy behavior of their competitors. Neither do consumers.
Meanwhile, people continue to take it from the cretins Seth referred to, rewarding these “businesses” for their behavior.
If folks keep buying from them and media outlets keep accepting their advertising, do you really think they are going to change?
Have you ever contacted a media outlet about the advertising they accepted from vendors advertising one thing and delivering another? Sure, it’s your word against the vendor’s. And yes, the media outlet will likely claim they have no responsibility for what appears in their paper, on their station or on their website.
I think you’re smarter than that.
The power of the customer to deal with these vendors comes simply: STOP BUYING FROM THESE IDIOTS.
It’s Just Word of Mouth
Businesses can help them do that.
Customers have lots of resources that enable them to take control, including Yelp, Urbanspoon, Angie’s List, Trip Advisor, etc. These services help people find businesses that deliver what they say and avoid the ones who don’t.
In a perfect world, we shouldn’t need any of them. Until we get there, we all have to help each other by calling BS when it’s warranted and giving kudos as well.
Too few businesses pay attention to those services. If you think no one is using them to make daily purchasing choices in your little town, you’re dead wrong – particularly if your area is frequented by tourists. You need to be monitoring them, addressing issues, “claiming” your business so people can find you, and encouraging consumers to share their thoughts there.
Encourage your customers to use tools that help them buy better. Provide them when you can. Help them stop buying from the wrong people.